2 diff/ user pictures with same Apple ID

I've been trying to figure this out guys but can't seem to find a way. I have 2 users on my MacBook Air and both are connected to my one and only Apple ID. When I change the picture on the 1 user in System Preferences>Users & Groups it changes the picture for the both users and on my Apple ID.

I just want to have one picture for one user and another picture for the second user without changing the Apple ID picture. Is there a way to do this?