Where on the Apple TV App is the Continue watching

Please verify the setting for Use Play History.

Continue Watching should be populated with content that you have added manually (while not completed), as well as content from supported content providers that you have started watching, but have not completed yet. For TV shows, this would count for released episodes: when you have watched all available episodes, the listing should get hidden until new content is released — because it is a queue list.

If there are multiple accounts on your Apple TV box, then verify that the correct account is active, as this watch history/​play history is administrated per account.

If Continue Watching is behaving erratically for you, then consider signing out (for Store services), then signing in again to refresh this account property.

How do I sign out? On the AppleTV?

Settings﹥Users and Accounts﹥ᴅᴇғᴀᴜʟᴛ ᴜsᴇʀ﹥Store﹥Sign Out

then sign in again.

If that doesn’t solve it, then please contact the Apple Support staff for further assistance.