Bug in Smart Playlist sync of blank genre field from iTunes (12.13.5.3) to iPhone (18.3.1)

I am posting this here because the feedback form for submitting bugs has a limit of 800 characters, and this bug cannot be described accurately within that limitation.


Problem: Smart playlists that contain a filter on the genre field are not syncing correctly with the iPhone when the genre of an item is blank.


Example: Song1 has no genre defined in its info. Song2 has the genre 'Rock' in its info. Song3 has the genre 'Blues' in its info. All three songs have the same artist, 'ArtistA.'


A smart playlist, 'Playlist1' is created in iTunes with the following criteria: Artist is 'ArtistA.' All other options are left at their default values.


A smart playlist, 'Playlist2' is created in iTunes with the following criteria: Artist is 'ArtistA.' Genre is not 'Jazz.' All other options are left at their default values.


The expected behavior of both Smart Playlists in iTunes is that both should correctly show all 3 songs, as all 3 songs have artist 'ArtistA' and none of the 3 songs are of the genre 'Jazz.' iTunes correctly does this.


The expected behavior when syncing both Smart Playlists with the iPhone is that both Smart Playlists will be accurately replicated on the device and will contain all 3 songs, just like in iTunes. This does not correctly occur, and instead we see the following:


On the iPhone, 'Playlist1' correctly shows all 3 songs in the music app as expected. 'Playlist2' however only shows Song2 and Song3. The inclusion of the filter "Genre is not 'Jazz'" in the iTunes Smart Playlist incorrectly excludes Song1, which has no defined genre. Only when Song1's info is modified in iTunes to have any data in the genre field (except of course 'Jazz'), will it then correctly be shown in the synced Smart Playlist on the iPhone.

Posted on Mar 10, 2025 03:48 PM

Reply

Similar questions

1 reply

Mar 11, 2025 09:35 AM in response to mrkorb

iTunes and Apple devices have never been completely consistent in their behaviour around metadata. Even if you get someone at Apple to notice your feedback or you can submit a bug report there is no guarantee they they will consider it to be an issue, that it will be fixed in a timely manner, or that it won't break again down the line. Given you've identified the behaviour you can now workaround it. Add genres to all your tracks, or create the playlists using positive filters. Or you could potentially take all your songs that don't have a genre now and edit to " ", "<empty>", or some other value you deem appropriate.


tt2

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Bug in Smart Playlist sync of blank genre field from iTunes (12.13.5.3) to iPhone (18.3.1)

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.