how do I disable automatic window resizing in Sequoia

Disable the Tiling options in System Settings > Desktop & Dock > Windows.

Me too! I hate this. I work on an iMac all day and am now wasting time to resize windows when I only intended to relocate them. This should be automatically off.

Thanks for confirming, @d.s.cobb! That's exactly the faulty behavior I had reported via Apple Feedback.

Here, it's a Mac Mini M2 Pro with a Dell UltraSharp 40" monitor (U4021QW). And that turned out to be the problem.

As suggested by Dell, I had installed Dell's DDPM software, and allowed it to open automatically on startup. That software has a feature called EasyArrange which allows, among other things, window tiling just like in Sequoia. I've never used it, though, and wasn't aware it was seemingly turned on (maybe it wasn't). For more than a year, it hasn't caused any issues.

Now that changed when updating to Sequoia. Don't ask me how this is possible, but the new macOS window tiling feature seems to have enabled the DDPM EasyArrange feature, with no way of disabling it.

From there on, fixing the issue was easy: Quit DDPM, and the nasty behavior immediately goes away. Go to Settings, Login Items & Extensions, Open at Login, and remove DDPM, so that it doesn't load on startup. Problem solved. This also explains why most people in this thread didn't encounter the problem the way I did.

If you don't use a Dell monitor, it might be your monitor vendor's software that macOS Sequoia plays fancy tricks with. Good luck sorting it out! (I'll post an addendum on Apple Feedback so they're aware of this problem.)

None of the suggestions resolved this issue for me. I am using two monitors - one laptop display and one 30" display. Windows move and stack (and don't tile) fine on the laptop display. However, any window that's dragged to the larger display causes two transparent boxes appear delineating the left and right halves of the screen - one outlined by yellow and one outlined by green. When I release the mouse over either of these boxes, the window being moved is resized to 1/2 the screen and tiled into that side of the display. I have ALL the tiling options disabled. This behavior started with Sequoia betas and still manifests in the GA release.

GAWD, that's an annoying default setting! Geez!

I must have a different version than everyone else. I just move the window slightly and the tile outline goes away and I can place the window anywhere. Does it not work like that for you?

Apple always defaults new toys to On.

I can assure you, based on 40 years in the Operating System business, that anytime an OS release breaks layered SW that uses supported public APIs, its developers would consider it a bug.

Without apps, an OS along is useless to anyone except programmers, so OS developers work VERY HARD to maintain backward compatibility, while ALSO releasing new features. If they need to break compatibility, they deprecate said API and announce an end-of-life release after which apps are no longer guaranteed to work. It is exactly these values that make Apple and MacOS beloved in the developer world.

CesareMedici wrote:

@dialabrain Never assume everyone's using the exact same setup as you. (In my case, it was a combination of Dell's DDPM monitor software and the Sequoia update that caused this hard-to-debug issue.)

I don't. And in your case it was the Dell software not being compatible with Sequoia. Not a Sequoia issue.

Of course @dialabrain. And if said developer suspects that a supported public interface has been broken, they are entitled and expected to file it as a bug - beta is as much a service to Apple as it is to the developer. Whether or when Apple fixes the broken API or the developer works around the bug is a business decision made by each party. It doesn't change the fact that breaking a supported public interface is a bug.

PatriceW999 wrote:

I'm looking at a variety of settings - which one will make the automatic sizing to full screen when I drag a window to the top of the screen?

https://discussions.apple.com/content/attachment/37a0e05e-9f43-4638-aff7-c8f32623f7b2

Tile by dragging windows to screen edges.

You can just choose to not use the suggestion. When the outline appears indicating which tile it is going to drop into, just move the window a little and the Tile will go away.

Tried disabling it, but still run into the same issue. I even disabled the other options just in case, but nothing. I am using the OS 24A335.

WigglyWaggly wrote:

Thank you! I am sure someone requested this feature, but nice to know you can make it go away.

I really have no need for it, but it is probably one of the most requested features I have seen on these forums.However, I don’t see how it’s obtrusive at all. I move my window where I want it. A little outline pops up. I moved the window a little bit more and the little outline goes away. I drop my window where I wanted it.

Follow this post:

CesareMedici

User level:

Level 1

60 points

Sep 28, 2024 11:50 AM in response to d.s.cobb

Thanks for confirming, @d.s.cobb! That's exactly the faulty behavior I had reported via Apple Feedback.

Here, it's a Mac Mini M2 Pro with a Dell UltraSharp 40" monitor (U4021QW). And that turned out to be the problem.

As suggested by Dell, I had installed Dell's DDPM software, and allowed it to open automatically on startup. That software has a feature called EasyArrange which allows, among other things, window tiling just like in Sequoia. I've never used it, though, and wasn't aware it was seemingly turned on (maybe it wasn't). For more than a year, it hasn't caused any issues.

Now that changed when updating to Sequoia. Don't ask me how this is possible, but the new macOS window tiling feature seems to have enabled the DDPM EasyArrange feature, with no way of disabling it.

From there on, fixing the issue was easy: Quit DDPM, and the nasty behavior immediately goes away. Go to Settings, Login Items & Extensions, Open at Login, and remove DDPM, so that it doesn't load on startup. Problem solved. This also explains why most people in this thread didn't encounter the problem the way I did.

That doesn't turn off tiling. It's a bug in Sequoia that I (and probably many others) have reported via Feedback Assistant. 3 Sequoia updates later, it's still not fixed.