Hello riverdog22,
Thank you for reaching out to Apple Support Communities.
Are these the steps you followed?
"Connect a Bluetooth device
- Make sure the device is turned on and discoverable (see the device’s documentation for details).
- On your Mac, choose Apple menu
> System Settings, then click Bluetooth
in the sidebar. (You may need to scroll down.) - Hold the pointer over the device in the list, then click Connect.
- If asked, click Accept (or enter a series of numbers, then press Enter).
You can also connect a Bluetooth device to your Mac by clicking the Bluetooth status icon
in the menu bar and choosing the device. If the icon isn’t shown in the menu bar, you can add it using Control Center settings."
More details can be found here: Connect a Bluetooth device with your Mac
If the issue persists, can you provide a few more details? Are you able to connect other Bluetooth devices to your Mac? Does the Chromecast work with other devices?
Cheers!