Ensuring openability/playability of older Logic Pro X Projects

Hi everyone!,


I have an old Macbook Pro (2017) with Mojave 10.14.6 and Logic Pro X Version 10.5.1. About 5 years ago I took everything I'd made on some older versions of Garageband on an old iPhone and iPad (both also from 2017), transferred them to the computer, opened and played through each in 10.5.1 (track by track, which, given the number, about 200, took several hours), determined that they all played correctly, that all the sounds/fx were in order, etc., and if there were any discrepancies between playback on the original device and Logic on the computer, they were minor. I then made some more tracks on the computer itself (using 10.5.1). The laptop's battery has nearly died completely, and, though I've seen that some Macbooks can be run with AC power alone, I'm not expecting to be able to use the computer for much longer and will likely have to get a new Macbook soon. All of the music is backed up on an external drive, but life got in the way and I was not able in this prior 5 year period to continue to work on it, so it has remained virtually untouched.


My two questions are: Can I expect whatever later version of Logic I end up with if I get a recently released Macbook Pro to play, with few or minimal compatibility issues, these older tracks, assuming they played fine in the version of Logic Pro X on which I checked them? I realize this is complex question because it can depend on whether later versions of Logic have eliminated or adjusted certain sound libraries/fx etc. that I may have used in these older tracks, which I obviously can't specify track by track here. And, if not, would it be possible to get the exact version of Logic Pro X I used on the 2017 laptop on the newer one, in order to ensure unproblematic playback? (I've seen mention of use of the "Purchased" tab in the App Store as one method).


Thanks for everyone's time,

John

Posted on May 24, 2025 09:17 AM

Reply

Similar questions

6 replies

May 24, 2025 02:26 PM in response to Hello4500

Logic Pro 11 is generally compatible with projects created in earlier versions of Logic Pro, including Logic Pro X, but not in a completely backward-compatible way. You can open projects created in Logic Pro 5 or later in Logic Pro 11, but when you do, the project will be converted to a Logic Pro 11 project format. This means some of the features and settings in the older project may be adjusted to match Logic Pro 11's standards.


I have not tried this but perhaps the EXS24 (Pre Logic Pro 10.5) to Sampler (Post Logic Pro 10.5) transition might give you issues. I would bounce to audio just in case if that is possible before transitioning.


2nd question is not that easy:

And, if not, would it be possible to get the exact version of Logic Pro X I used on the 2017 laptop on the newer one, in order to ensure unproblematic playback? (I've seen mention of use of the "Purchased" tab in the App Store as one method).


You would need a laptop or computer that has the appropriate and compatible OS to get the exact version of Logic Pro.


This thread covers it well:

Logic Pro not compatible with my Ventura … - Apple Community


Besides that, you should be solid. If I think of anything else, I will add to the thread. Cheers!


Eddie G.


May 26, 2025 09:07 AM in response to Hello4500

Bounce to audio means you consolidate everything into one audio file. In the example below, I have a track and it has several FX. I am going to "Bounce to Audio" so my CPU no longer has to process all of those plug-ins. This is a great technique for CPU management but also works great as I will no longer need to rely on the FX in the future as the sound is "Printed" into audio. (Key Command is ctrl+b)



May 24, 2025 03:03 PM in response to Hello4500

(track by track, which, given the number, about 200, took several hours),

You can speed it up by using the command File > Export > Export x or All tracks as Audio Files. The export of all tracks takes the same time as a stereo bounce. You need to create the aux/return busses in the main window in order to have them exported as well. The tracks then all have the same starting point, which can be imported into any software and version.


Nobody can look into the future. There is no eternal compatibility of software. The most compatible and future resistant files are audio WAF-files. Concerning Logic, you can always try to copy an older version to your new computer and see if it works. You need to rename the old logic.app and can place it into the application folder next to the most recent version of Logic. But as soon as the architecture of the software, macos and computer don't match anymore, it won't work.

May 25, 2025 02:48 PM in response to Hello4500

Hi guys,


Thanks so much for this helpful info. I must say it's a little more ominous and uncertain than I was expecting and has me a bit worried. Especially your last paragraph, "yoyoben." Though I understand it's correct and justified. 


I have never used (as far as I know) any samplers of the sort you describe, Eddie, nor have I ever used any third party plug-ins, so I suppose that eliminates one source of incompatibility. I have always tried to only use the basic stuff available within any DAW. I just opened up a random track and sounds I see are things (synths and drums) like "Hip hop sub bass," "lunar pools," "deep tech," "classic drum machine," "classic simple pad," "digital wave," "dark matter," "arcade synth," etc. And for each of these, of course, some effects. "Remix FX" applied to the master often. I don't own the newer computer yet, nor, because of its price, do I expect to very soon, and as of yet no one has come out of the woodwork to offer me 10 hours of free use of their M4 Pro with the latest version of Logic (which would allow me to test the tracks..when I said "track by track," in my original post, I meant each individual song. I realize "track" means each individual piece of a song.)


So..is there any manual or tool or guidebook by which I might get a rough sense of what will work and what won't (the "some features and settings" you mention, Eddie), so that, if necessary, I can..."bounce to audio," as you recommend, sooner rather than later, and not risk problems when the death of my current one necessitates a transition? I get that there are "sound libraries" (?) (where I find "Arcade Synth," say), effects, and other features of various kinds, for any DAW, some of which you have to get outside the DAW and use within it. But that's about the limit of my knowledge. I put "bounce to audio" in quotes because I'm still a little hazy on the meaning of this. I've started to bounce the entire songs to files playable within iTunes, just so if things go awry, I have a playable version of what I ended up with, but you guys seem to be saying that within a song you can (what I remember might be called "freeze" in Cubase, the other DAW I use) bounce each individual track as a piece of audio and then when the entire song is opened up later, elsewhere, what plays is the collection of those frozen pieces of audio (no real time processing of the audio is required of the DAW, and so no incompatibilities)...In that case, are you rendering anything frozen unalterable/uneditable in the future? Ideally, I'd keep each part editable, even if that comes at the expense of a few occasional glitches after the transfer. 


Also, is this the sort of laptop on which I might get Mojave or another not up-to-date OS, where I could use the older version of Logic? 

https://www.bestbuy.com/site/apple-macbook-pro-13-3-certified-refurbished-intel-core-i5-2-3ghz-with-8gb-memory-256gb-ssd-2017-silver/6465448.p?skuId=6465448

I also see nothing online suggesting that the newest Macbook Pro available would not run the version of Logic I have currently, so that seems like the first step if I have compatibility issues. 


Finally, I'm happy you suggested the idea of backing up the application itself, because I found this page

Back up Logic Pro for Mac - Apple Support

and it seems to describe the solution you're talking about... that doesn't require the use of the "Purchased" tab at all? 


I apologize for the length, just really want to understand the situation better,

John

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Ensuring openability/playability of older Logic Pro X Projects

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.