Apple Music (the app, not the service) smart playlist rules/limits not functioning as expected

This used to work and I am unsure of when it broke.

I am on a Mac mini M4 with Sequoia 15.4.1, Music is version 1.5.4.70


I have many smart playlists which I use like algorithms to serve up my music in ways that please me, for me.


My issue is within the playlist rules, when using limits. One is given the option to select tracks by a set of predetermined choices, in particular "most often played" and "least often played". Neither of these options do what they say.


For instance, I have a smart playlist (BRAP) with 1578 songs. 910 of those songs have play information. Only 56 of these tracks have been played 2 or more times. When I create another smart playlist (BRAP Most) that takes BRAP and limits the list to 242 MB selected by "most often played", I get a playlist with ~242 MB of songs from BRAP but have not play counts, no play information. I know I have 910 songs that have more play counts than the ones in the new list.


Same thing, if I limit for "least often played" the resulting list is exactly the same as what is produced with "most often played".


This simply does not make sense to me.


My workaround is add a 2nd row to the matches, match all, and match Plays to "is greater than" and "2". With this I have a list of my most often played of BRAP. (If I say greater than "1" however, I get a 242 MB list of tracks that have been played exactly 2 times, go figure!)


For BRAP Least, I set Plays to 0, and limit my selection by "random" and that works well enough for now.


I know this functionality worked about a decade ago when I set it up, albeit it was iTunes at the time.


I also tested Most and Least Often, neither of those function correctly either.


Mac mini, macOS 15.4

Posted on Apr 28, 2025 02:21 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on May 19, 2025 08:22 AM

No change in 15.5

Similar questions

2 replies

Apr 28, 2025 05:43 PM in response to oZmonKey

This seems to be a new bug introduced with Sequoia 15.4.1 with no workaround. Just a ridiculously stupid bug that ruins all smart playlists that use the "Limit to" option. It's especially broken when using "Limit to" and selecting "most recently added," which just doesn't work. Steve Jobs would've fired people over such obvious coding errors. This isn't the first report on the problem (there's another thread about this) and Reddit has taken notice, too.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Apple Music (the app, not the service) smart playlist rules/limits not functioning as expected

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.