Music doesn't count last track played

This has been reported before but that discussion is closed and I just noticed that the problem exists in the latest release of Ventura. see: Music doesn't count last track played - Apple Community


When Music plays the last track of a playlist, it does not update the play count. The file is on internal hard disk in the default Music library location. I have observed this on m4a and aif files. I haven't tried mp3 files.


I'm running Ventura 13.3.1 on a mac mini M1, Music version 1.3.4.56


This is a silly bug. Apple: please acknowledge this bug and fix it.


Mac mini, macOS 13.3

Posted on Apr 19, 2023 10:04 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Jun 3, 2023 02:20 PM

just updated to 13.4 and Music 1.3.5.8 and the problem is not fixed.


I am actually amazed that such a bug could even exist because to create a bug like this a software engineer has to do something extraordinary. You would think that the code would do something like this:

when song ends, add 1 to the play count.

I.e. nice and simple. No matter what else is going on, if the song finished playing, the play count should be incremented. I mean, isn't that what the play count is? a count of the number of times the song has been played? No matter if it was played on airplay or on the computer's speakers or streamed over the internet? A play is a play.


but instead, the software engineer has to write something like this:

when song ends, check something unrelated, complicated and illogical and if that's true, don't add 1 to the playcount.

But then, I guess I don't understand how the current generation of software engineers thinks.


I see that this problem has been around for a while. I expect we'll see a fix to this extremely complex and difficult problem sometime in the next few years.


BTW if the play count matters to you, you can create an audio file (mp3, aiff, whatever) with 1 second of silence and add that to the end of the playlist.

Similar questions

4 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Jun 3, 2023 02:20 PM in response to dotore

just updated to 13.4 and Music 1.3.5.8 and the problem is not fixed.


I am actually amazed that such a bug could even exist because to create a bug like this a software engineer has to do something extraordinary. You would think that the code would do something like this:

when song ends, add 1 to the play count.

I.e. nice and simple. No matter what else is going on, if the song finished playing, the play count should be incremented. I mean, isn't that what the play count is? a count of the number of times the song has been played? No matter if it was played on airplay or on the computer's speakers or streamed over the internet? A play is a play.


but instead, the software engineer has to write something like this:

when song ends, check something unrelated, complicated and illogical and if that's true, don't add 1 to the playcount.

But then, I guess I don't understand how the current generation of software engineers thinks.


I see that this problem has been around for a while. I expect we'll see a fix to this extremely complex and difficult problem sometime in the next few years.


BTW if the play count matters to you, you can create an audio file (mp3, aiff, whatever) with 1 second of silence and add that to the end of the playlist.

Jun 6, 2023 10:00 AM in response to dotore

I've been running into this ever since upgrading to Ventura and it's really annoying.


What I have discovered in my case is that play counts are not counted only if Airplaying to a device or using Airpods. If you play your files directly through the computers speakers it seems to work.


I have never run into this before with any iteration of Music so having to rely on workarounds like the 1 second thing just seems like it should be so unnecessary.


I've reported this as a bug every time there's an update and am starting to think it'll never be fixed.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Music doesn't count last track played

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.