Apple Card not listed as option for payment

I use this card sparingly online because Goldman Sachs is really great at resolving disputes. That said, I can never pick it from a list of available cards (I have one other card in Wallet and that one is always what shows up, but it is the only option). I can go to the card details and get the Apple Card number and type it in myself, and that works. I use LastPass and maybe that's a factor too, but LastPass knows about both cards as well and I can't see any difference in the settings for the two cards.