Manually adding faces to Photo does not work as described in the manual

Hello!


In my Photo application (ver. 8.0 (560.0.114)) on Macbook Pro 13" late 2017 with Ventura 13.7.7 (22H722), circles of manually added faces in photos do not move (and do not change in diameter). All added face circles are located in one place in the center of the photo and when you try to move them/change the diameter of the circle, the entire photo moves. When you select a context menu in the face circle area, only the menu item "this is not a face" appears.


Please tell me how to fix it!

MacBook Pro 13″, macOS 13.7

Posted on Jul 30, 2025 07:49 PM

Reply
12 replies

Aug 4, 2025 10:56 AM in response to o13g

As macgirldc wrote - you can just click into the name field wherever the circle is, and only then adjust it. However, this way the faces thumbnail may be wrong, initially.

You can also click somewhere into the background - somewhere outside any faces circle to bring the focus back to the photo you are working with. Then you should be able to move and adjust the faces circle.

if none of this helps, quit photos and restart it. And if all fails, restart your Mac.

See: Work-Around: What to do, when the Faces Circle is jumping around - Apple Community




Aug 4, 2025 11:01 AM in response to o13g

o13g wrote: … when you try to move them/change the diameter of the circle, the entire photo moves.

Yeah, that happens. Sometimes the circle refuses to move, because Photos thinks you're still in the info window and you want to drag the picture there, or something like that. In that case you need to tap on the picture to let Photos know you mean the picture, and then you can move the circle. Or, you can just type the name first, and then move the circle.  


Ahh--once again léonie and I are typing at the same time! We've both had to deal with this stuck circle problem!

Aug 4, 2025 04:30 PM in response to o13g

Thank you very much for the advice - tried everything, but it didn't help. Now the problem is gone, but in a strange way... I downloaded FaceExplorer, it scanned the library and the circles started moving and changing in size! It was like it kicked the library and it woke up :) I understand, it sounds like "dancing with a tambourine", but it worked. Also, the album "Unnamed" appeared, which was not possible to achieve with smart albums.

Aug 4, 2025 04:32 PM in response to macgirldc

Thank you very much for the advice - tried everything, but it didn't help. Now the problem is gone, but in a strange way... I downloaded FaceExplorer, it scanned the library and the circles started moving and changing in size! It was like it kicked the library and it woke up :) I understand, it sounds like "dancing with a tambourine", but it worked. Also, the album "Unnamed" appeared, which was not possible to achieve with smart albums.

Aug 4, 2025 11:20 PM in response to Richard.Taylor

Indeed. we should not use it on our main libraries without more than one backup, and the backups should be tested. Face Explorer is a great project by Tim Felix Beyer, but I would take the author's caution seriously. He stated in the documentation to the app:

"Warning: Although everything should be safe, I am not responsible for any data loss - proceed at your own risk

...

This project is my first macOS application in Swift. 

...

  • (Work in progress) Enables users to assign names to the faces right from the app. This is a bit scary because it requires writing to the photos library database."


Aug 5, 2025 01:38 AM in response to Richard.Taylor

Thank you very much for the warning about the use of third-party tools and the reminder of the importance of backup - I remember it! We have to admit that if the original problem is not solved by system tools or updates (which, unfortunately, are no longer available 2017>2025:), then restoring the backup of the system library will most likely lead to a state where the original problem is present... It turns out that the backup is important not only of the system photo library, but also the photos themselves to start again in the system or third-party application:(

Aug 5, 2025 03:14 AM in response to o13g

Can you upgrade your Mac to macOS 15 Sequoia? I noticed the problem with the manually added faces circles first in macOS 10.15 Catalina, and it persisted for several system versions. It seems to be fixed in Sequoia, however, at least, I have not noticed it any longer in the current system version so far, but the upgrade might not be possible for a 2017 MacBook Pro.





Aug 5, 2025 06:57 AM in response to léonie

léonie wrote: He stated in the documentation to the app:
"Warning: Although everything should be safe, I am not responsible for any data loss - proceed at your own risk
...
This project is my first macOS application in Swift. 
...
(Work in progress) Enables users to assign names to the faces right from the app. This is a bit scary because it requires writing to the photos library database• ."

I read that, as well, and it made my skin crawl! This sounds very exciting, but I would only use it on a Photos Library that I wouldn't mind losing.


I think that a recommendation to try this out should be accompanied by an appropriate full warning, like

"use this app only on a copy of a Photos Library that you wouldn't mind losing."

Manually adding faces to Photo does not work as described in the manual

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.