18.2 bug stops complex HomeKit automations from working

Do you have some HomeKit automations set up that suddenly stopped working after your Home hub (HomePod or Apple TV) updated to 18.2, and you're losing the will to live trying to diagnose what happened? It's not you, it's an insidious and obscure bug in 18.2. If you have automations that do not only set scenes or accessories but are shortcuts, and these shortcuts contain the 'Calculate' action, this action will fail. It works if you test the automation in the Home app, whether step by step in the godawful shortcut designer (with the 'play' button) or if you just tap 'Test Automation', but it silently crashes if the automation triggers normally.

I reported this bug with the Feedback app during the 18.2 beta cycle, but it nonetheless made it to the final release. It's obscure and probably doesn't affect that many people, so who knows when it'll get fixed - meanwhile the only solution I found is to downgrade a HomePod to 18.1 and hope it stays there.

HomePod mini, 18

Posted on Dec 15, 2024 6:19 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Jan 5, 2025 1:37 PM

Interesting… maybe the problem is more nuanced than I thought. It can be confusing because Personal Automations (triggered directly on your iPhone or iPad) are different from Home Automations (triggered by your Home hub, like a HomePod or Apple TV). The personal ones may work as expected since they run directly on your device with fewer background restrictions.


I just realized that some of my Get Contents of URL Shortcuts (which are still working) are not started via Home Automations but rather through Hazel or Keyboard Maestro scripts running on my home Mac. Those execute flawlessly, likely because they’re not constrained by the HomeKit environment. However, the same actions embedded in Home Automations fail for me, just like you’re experiencing.


So the temporary workaround would either be using a Home Hub that is on 18.1 OR using one of the third party automation tools to kick off from a computer that's always on.

Similar questions

31 replies

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

18.2 bug stops complex HomeKit automations from working

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.