You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!

When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Why is controlling a HomePod so hard from iOS?

I am not talking about Airplay. Rather, playing Music from the HomePod.

I have a Mini in another room and do not want to yell to get it playing.

But the UI and UX for Apple Music and Home app is just terrible to get it started and then, if you go back to adjust volume, it is replaced by the iPhone (which is playing nothing). So you have to go to Control other speakers… (COST) to bring it up.

I fully understand how to use all of this and use Airplay and COST all the time. But to get things started and controlling the “other speaker” — the Apple made HomePod — is all but unusable.

Often, while trying to get the Mini to simply play something (other than by voice), both the iPhone and the Mini end up playing the same thing, but individually! So it is like an echo/delay. Absolutely ridiculous that this is even possible unintentionally.

HomePod mini

Posted on Jul 22, 2024 9:30 AM

Reply
4 replies

Jul 23, 2024 8:26 AM in response to IdrisSeabright

Idris, you know me. You know I know about Feedback and use it. So you know I am actually not complaining but rather, using a rhetorical device to find out if there is a proper way to play from HomePods, but control and start from iOS. Sans Airplay.

Regardless, it is a question! What is the proper way to start from and control a HomePod from iOS?

Jul 23, 2024 8:44 AM in response to Ataraxy01

Ataraxy01 wrote:

What is the proper way to start from and control a HomePod from iOS?

The proper way is by using AirPlay, so not sure why that is not what you want to do. In the Music app, you simply choose the AirPlay icon on the bottom of the screen and the HomePods will show as a destination. After selected you can control the volume and skip songs from the Lock Screen of your iPhone, Music app, or use Siri on the HomePods to play a different song and that will be reflected on the iPhone as well. I don't use the Home app at all.

Jul 23, 2024 9:26 AM in response to Mac Jim ID

I do that all the time and have for as long as Airplay has existed. But I have a situation where I want to start it without voice, playing from the HomePod, sans Airplay. This is possible but, the way I am doing it is apparently not the right way and, from what I can tell, the right way is nutty.

Here is how to make it work but, it is nutty:

Go to control panel, choose Airplay (!) icon. Hit Control Other Speaker… button, choose the HomePod. Then go to Apple Music, do not hit the default HomePod play (unless it is what you want). Instead first choose what you want to play, like a station or playlist, when you do that, it changes on the HomePod control in Apple Music and you can hit play.

Ugh. Apple. Why? (Yes, Idris, I have sent this one in.)

Would it not make more sense to have this all in the Music App and have the user start the music and be able to easily and reliably choose the speaker? Instead, you start at the end for it to work.

The gold standard for UI and UX simplicity remains: Connect.

If I am missing something, that is the question I am posting here. No, it is not Airplay. Again, I am pretty much the master at that. I even have Airport Express v2 with older firmware playing from iOS and macOS to ensure it is 16/44 lossless. But, like with the HomePod, which is only Airplay 2, I also use that all the time plus, the ability for a HomePod to send Airplay 2 as 24/96 to better powered speakers I have. So I have Airplay covered. That is not the question here.

Why is controlling a HomePod so hard from iOS?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.