Scarlett 4i4 line 2 signal not going through to Garage band?

I have 2 lines plugged in for a Podcast, one is a Mic using 48v power, the other is a Inst 1/4". I can hear both signals through the headphones, but only the main mic (48v) on line 1 input shows a recordable line level in garage band. I can hear and see the line 2 level on Scarlett and hear it through the headphone, but the signal is not making it to Garage band track 2. Record settings are set at input 1-2, as well as I tried each track at input settings 1, 2 separately, still no signal from line 2 input, though I can hear both through the headphones.

I also went to Security settings to make sure the Garage band Mic setting were allowed....Any help and suggestions much appreciated.