Mulitlple cameras on Mas OS 13 undifferentiated

When I run obs I always seem to have a problem with OBS not being able to lock on to one of my 12 sq11 cameras. USB tree they all show as general UVC cameras.


The problem is OBS relies on a particular name of a camera in order to lock on it and there's no way to define a name on any of the 12 cameras I use. Obs sees that as ambiguous and can't do anything with about that.


Is there currently a way you could label the 12 different cameras with something, anything, even if it's just one or two alphanumeric characters that can associate cameras 1 through 6 and left and right eye. Technically I don't even need that because it's obvious which ones are left eyes: the ones that are obviously upside down when in the raw. If I could add 12 cameras and only had a single extra character, I could label them zero through nine and a and b.


I looked inside some of the operating system stuff there's no way you could change the name of the camera to anything but general UVC. Some people say it's a hard disk well this thing doesn't have memory so therefore I can't assign a name to it and have it stick.


We'll wait a second there is an SD card slot but we kind of a waste just to put an SD slot just to keep the name of a camera intact. I just need the 12 cheapest micro SD cards to hold the name which would be of the 1 GB or less variety. I'm wondering if that will hold their names.

Mac mini, macOS 13.1

Posted on Feb 3, 2023 5:47 PM

Reply

Similar questions

3 replies

Feb 5, 2023 2:16 PM in response to tripletopper

According to a couple different conversations we found out a few things.


Mac OS did have a feature of numbering identically named USB items. I had this feature in Mac OS 10.13 I noticed i lost this feature when I got a new computer and it was updated to Mac OS 12.


Also it seems like an issue of the right hand not knowing what the left hand is doing. Apple is expecting camera makers to have a way to rename a camera. Camera makers are expecting Apple to differentiate between identically named stuff somehow like Auto numbering like that was apparent in OS 10.13.


I think it's a bigger than a camera issue because also I have two microphones one on one studio setup one on the other and they are undifferentiated and every time the computer goes off the OBS program loses track of which one is which and you have to reset it.


So it's not an issue with cameras or microphones per se, but the relationship between the OS and the USB items that plug into it.


Originally I wanted to name each camera personally so that I don't have to memorize numbers associated with cameras. Apparently Apple left that up to the usb device makers, and enough device makers left that up to Apple.


The people who run OBS project say that if the operating system won't let you differentiate them then there's nothing OBS can do. I assume Apple assumes that software makers use the USB tree to differentiate One USB item from another if you're using a multi camera system like obs for Twitch streaming.


And it's weird to assume every camera has a memory, because a webcam by definition has no memory. It's just plug and stream live.


And if you tell me to write the camera manufacturer, I would like to know who exactly is the camera manufacturer of the device called an sq-11?

Feb 16, 2023 1:02 PM in response to tripletopper

Well, we're up to os 13.2.1 and still no differentiation of cameras OR microphone inputs at the "visible" OS level.


There might be some little differences in the underlying code, but OBS relies on locking on to a USB name, and if names are unable to be differentiated, then OBS is confused. It can't lock on to camera 1 and camera 2. OBS is locking on by name and not by underlying data. The makers of OBS say it's up to Apple to fix this.

Mar 5, 2023 8:14 PM in response to tripletopper

The people OBS say there's nothing they could do as long as the Mac OS does not differentiate between multiple cameras of the same type ( or microphones or anything else of that matter)


I know as early as Mac OS 10.13 there was a number in parentheses automatically assigned to each multiple version of the same thing so they could not be confused.


Could you at least go back to that having numbers in parentheses when identical items appear in the USB bus so that OBS and other similar apps could deal with it properly.


What's more logical to assume that someone would have 12 different cameras or 12 cameras of the same type? I need those sq-11s because that's the only way I could get two cameras within 2 inches of each other to make a stereoscopic pair. Every other camera just has too much bulky stuff around it where you can't line them up as a stereoscopic pair.


Yes we researched the company and there's a whole bunch of people selling these sq-11s. Apple told me to call the manufacturer then the question becomes who is the manufacturer and apple said we're in a real mess here because no one wants to take responsibility for these sq-11s at a consumer level.


If Apple is relying on camera makers to change names and app makers are relying on Apple to differentiate different cameras at the same type, then unless my suggestion of going back and numbering those various connections is back in play, it looks like we're at an impasse.


Why did Apple get rid of the numbering system of multiple connecting items that are identical? That fact makes OBS unstable and OBS unable to connect on various cameras unless I'm willing to keep the computer on for more than 24 hours at a time which is not healthy to do usually.


I don't want to spend 20 minutes before you show honing in on my cameras and unplugging and replugging stuff just to get the things connected I want connected.


Do you have any suggestions for me and how I can make this quicker without having my computer on overnight in a standby mode?

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Mulitlple cameras on Mas OS 13 undifferentiated

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.