Really depends on what you’re after. VLC is great. It has been the most stable and reliable solution for years, has proven itself very well. It plays pretty much anything you throw at it, but if you want something that feels more in sync with macOS Tahoe, there are definitely other options. Some media players just work better with touchpad gestures, HDR, and Apple Silicon, and that can make a big difference, especially if you watch a lot of high-bitrate videos.
Another thing is how well a player handles different formats, subtitles, and audio tracks. Some don’t deal well with MKV files that have multiple audio tracks, and others completely mess up ***/SSA subtitles, which is super annoying if you rely on them. Even AirPlay and external display support can be hit or miss—some players handle scaling and audio passthrough fine, while others just don’t.
And honestly, VLC hasn’t really changed much over the years. It does the job, but if you’re looking for something that fits better with macOS and has a more modern UI, there are definitely some solid alternatives out there.