Apple Watch Ultra 2 double tap Smart Stack select not working

I have my double tap on and under Smart Stack I have it set to Select however when I double tap from my watch face and bring up the Smart Stack it just advances through after every subsequent double tap. I just want to be able to select the first item on my Smart Stack hands free!

I can’t seem to find anyone else with the same issue.

I have tried turning off double tap, doing a hard reset and then turning it back on but it still won’t select it always advances