How do I separate all-day Reminders notifications for individual check-off in Notification Center?

I use my Notification Center as a sort of “to-do list” for myself. As I get notifications, I leave them in my Notification Center until I’ve completed the related task. In the past, I’ve had 3 Reminders set to go off at 3 separate times of day, and those have helped me for daily to-dos.

Recently, I decided to add a couple more “all day” Reminders to go off early in the morning and stay all day until I complete the task, even if it’s at the end of the day.

Unfortunately, now this is happening.

When it comes as one single notification like this, I can’t check individual items off as I complete the tasks throughout the day. Based on some other advice, I turned off “Notification grouping,” but that hasn’t changed anything. I don’t mind if the notifications stack, I just don’t want them to appear as one notification.

Here’s another screenshot of the way my Reminders list is set up.

Any suggestions?

[Re-Titled by Moderator]