Peter Paul van de Wijs wrote:
It seems a bit of a contradiction to replace my machine which is in a workable condition while donating it. If it works I should be able to continue using it right?
A 21.5" 2011 iMac in working condition might be useful for running applications that you already have, importing digital video from old MiniDV and Digital8 camcorders, or running old 32-bit games which are incompatible with Catalina and later.
You can still get a few applications that might help you get a bit more use out of that machine:
- The Firefox 115 ESR Web browser
- An older, unsupported version of the LibreOffice office suite, from the archives
- The GNU Image Manipulation Program (GIMP)
- Carbon Copy Coner and SuperDuper! – though not necessarily the current versions
But forget running modern Mac applications. Microsoft and Adobe abandoned High Sierra long ago. High Sierra isn't even enough to run the current versions of Firefox, Brave, Edge, Chrome, LibreOffice, or Affinity applications. Since even developers who support old versions of macOS have abandoned High Sierra, you really are fighting an uphill battle to keep using that machine, going forward, for applications that you do not already have.
If you still want to keep using it yourself, that's fine. If you donate it or sell it, you should make certain that the new owner knows that they are getting an outdated computer system. If they think they're getting a computer that will support modern applications, and be easy to find applications for, they'll be sadly disappointed.