How do I stop Safari from opening every file I download when done?

I often have to download multiple video and picture files using safari and whenever anything completes downloading it opens each file which is really annoying because I lose track of which files I was hovering over when the file opens over it and I have to close the window to get back to what I was working on.

I see people saying it's in "preferences" but that seems outdated as I am running MacOS 14.2.1 and there is no preferences section - only settings and the option I see they recommend unchecking does not appear to be there anymore and I can't find anything online other than using the preferences method.

Any help is welcome! Thank you.