You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!

When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Burn a Blu-Ray Disk

I have a LG Blu-Ray drive model BE12LU38 that works fine except it will not burn a Blu-Ray (BD) disk in Mac OS Ventura (13.1) Finder using my Mac Studio computer. It is connected using a USB cable. I am able to burn CD's and DVD's but not BD disks. I get an error saying "Disk Title.fpbf" is too large to fit on the disk. Remove some files and try again. This is when I try to burn from the Finder by dragging the files into the open BD window. The Finder creates an alias for each file, but fails to burn when I select Burn to Disc... from the File menu. Instead I get the error above. I tried removing several GB of files and it still fails with the same error. I am trying to burn about 20GB of data to a 25GB BD disk.


The drive works fine on an old Mac running Mac OS 10.13.6 and using Toast. Do I really need to spend $100 to buy Toast for my Mac Studio? Any other options? I thought the Mac OS was able to do this.


BTW, I am not trying to create a movie BD disk, just a BD data disk.

Posted on Jan 2, 2023 12:32 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Jan 7, 2023 2:36 PM

Your note that even 10 GB wouldn't go made me wonder if Apple had changed the system not to burn any disk bigger than a standard DVD - about 4.2 GB of data.


I quick erased a rewritable 25 GB Blu-ray disk with Toast, then set up a Burn folder with 21 GB of data. The OS burned the disk without issue.


So, it does still work in Ventura. I just don't have a way to explain why it's not working on your end.

Similar questions

7 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Jan 7, 2023 2:36 PM in response to laserski

Your note that even 10 GB wouldn't go made me wonder if Apple had changed the system not to burn any disk bigger than a standard DVD - about 4.2 GB of data.


I quick erased a rewritable 25 GB Blu-ray disk with Toast, then set up a Burn folder with 21 GB of data. The OS burned the disk without issue.


So, it does still work in Ventura. I just don't have a way to explain why it's not working on your end.

Jan 7, 2023 12:38 PM in response to lkrupp

Thanks for your reply.


Mac OS has long supported burning data to Blu-Ray. It is only that the recent Mac OS version is hit or miss. My LG Blu-Ray drive does work to burn discs from the Finder in old versions of Mac OS X.


I understand the many issues facing Blu-Ray as a video storage medium with all the licensing, cost, copy protection, and other factors. However, I already have a very large collection of videos, much of it on optical discs of one sort or another, and I have had almost no issues with reliability or long term storage (thus far). In fact my son has been telling me for years to move to hard disk based video storage, and I have done that for the most part, but I still like the ability of taking a disc to a family member's house and playing it on their set-top optical player. In my experience very few people out of the general public are geeky enough to have a computer connected TV that would play a USB stick of family videos. And I don't want to bring along a laptop of my own to do it. I want to leave the family history video with them, as a gift, that they can play when they want to. They want something that works like the other videos they play. So I like being able to bring or send something that works for them. I have been doing it for many years and it works well using my older Mac. It was only when I got my Mac Studio that I started having issues with burning Blu-ray Discs.


I know technology moves on, but I also have a laser engraver that requires Mac OS 9 to function. Should I throw away a $20,000.00 laser because it does not work with the latest technology? Instead I have a nice dual processor G4 Quicksilver Mac (and a backup) that boots into OS 9, and I use it routinely. I am not a business. I am a hobbyist. I like the old stuff. And where it is possible, I like the new stuff. Is that so bad?


My wife just read my post and told me that I should mention that I am an old codger who likes doing things the way I do them. I think that is a bit strong, but it is starting to hit pretty close to home...


Thanks again for your comments. I really do appreciate them!

Jan 7, 2023 12:45 PM in response to Kurt Lang

Thanks very much for reaching out with an idea on what might be wrong.


I tried doing that (removing some files). In fact I went all the way down to 10GB with no improvement. And I was able to burn the full 24.5GB folder of files to a BD disc using the borrowed drive. So the amount that is wasted is not the issue in this case. It is simply that the new Mac OS does not support my drive (any more). But thanks for the idea.


In case anyone is wondering, System Profiler does show a 25GB Blu-Ray disc inserted into the drive, so the OS does see and read the optical disc size correctly. But for some reason, they just don't support burning it.

Jan 7, 2023 9:51 AM in response to laserski

macOS has never, EVER, supported Blu-ray. Steve Jobs even wrote a white paper describing it as a bag of hurt, but that was in terms of playing or burning videos. As for data storage, as you can see, it’s a hit or miss proposition. Again, for Blu-ray you are on your own. macOS does not support it natively. It may work, it may not.


And Blu-ray is now considered obsolete technology by many as a data storage option. SSDs or USB sticks are more reliable, store more, and last longer.

Burn a Blu-Ray Disk

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.