Why can’t I reinstall macOS High Sierra even from recovery mode on iMac?

I cannot boot high sierra and cannot reinstall - either from recovery or standalone installer. The installer acts as if it has done its job and then I get the message that "Mac OS could not be installed on your computer". Not "High Sierra" but "Mac OS". I've tried all the methods and get the same results.



[Re-Titled by Moderator]

iMac Pro (2017)

Posted on May 1, 2025 01:16 AM

Reply
2 replies

May 4, 2025 12:54 PM in response to D.I. Johnson

I tried three methods. I've owned Macs since my first Classic in the 80s so I do understand them fairly well.

I had a bootable High Sierra that I had used previously to install on two desktop pros and one iMac. That was my first attempt and I tried it several times with the same negative result.

I tried Command R. Disc Utility could not unmount so I couldn't do first aid. In Recovery it would open an installer and go through the entire process to the bitter end and then say the same thing - that Mac OS could not be installed on this computer.

I did have a time machine backup. I could not get to it because the system did not show files and would not open a finder search window.

I tried using CCC that was on a usb enclosure with a 1TB HDD. CCC could not see the iMac.

There was no way I could see any of the files on the iMac. Just a blank page even though it did boot. I also tried starting in safe mode but still no files showed up. I used pram reset to no avail. However it would always go into recovery mode but would not finish the installation, stopping at the very end with the same message.

So I gave up. In recovery disc utility I erased the drive.

I made a new bootable installer and with the erased drive I was able to install High Sierra. I had lost some very important files that are not on Cloud. The resulting installation looked nothing like what I had before though and now there is yet another problem:

The sound preference has only sound input options of microphone or line input. So I have no sound from videos or iTunes. And it refuses to install Soundflower which always has worked before.

At least I can use the iMac again even though I lost everything.

Thanks for your time.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Why can’t I reinstall macOS High Sierra even from recovery mode on iMac?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.